February 13, 2024

We Compared the Top 4 Window Replacement Companies and Here’s What We Found

Home Improvement / We Compared the Top 4 Window Replacement Companies and Here’s What We Found

When you’re looking to replace the windows in your home, you’ll want to work with the window replacement company that best suits your needs.

During your search, there are likely a few names in the industry you’ll come across, including Renewal by Andersen, Pella, Marvin, and Champion.

Check out our #1 choice!

We’ll break down the differences between these options to help you understand which company is the right fit for you, in key areas like financing, warranties, material, installation, and custom design options.

A Brief Comparison of Window Replacement Companies

	Renewal by Andersen	Pella	Marvin	Champion
Warranty Length	20 Years	Varies	Varies	20 Years
Transferable Warranty	Yes	Depends	Yes	No
Maintenance Required by Warranty*	No Maintenance Required	Maintenance Required	Maintenance Required	Maintenance Required
Material	Fibrex® Material	Vinyl, Wood, Fiberglass	Wood, Extruded Aluminum, Fiberglass	Vinyl
Financing Available	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Custom Design	Hundreds of Custom Design Options	Limited 5 Operable Shapes	Some Options for each Material	Range of Colors and Designs

*Most window replacement companies require proof of routine window maintenance before addressing issues.

Check out our #1 choice!

Renewal by Andersen

Renewal by Andersen has installed nearly 2 million windows in over 300,000 homes in the US and for good reason. In every category measured, Renewal by Andersen provides an exceptional experience.

Warranty Length: 20 Years

Transferable Warranty: Fully Transferable

Maintenance Required: No Maintenance Required

Material: Fibrex®, Andersen Exclusive

Financing: Exclusive Payment Options Available

Installation: Certified Master Installers

Custom Design: Hundreds of options, diverse long-lasting colors

Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

If you want to work with a company that provides impressive quality through and through, Renewal by Andersen is an excellent choice. With the nation’s best warranty coverage that requires no maintenance on your part, exclusive materials, great financing, convenient scheduling with same-day appointments in some markets, best-in-class installers, and hundreds of custom design options, Renewal by Andersen offers everything you’d need.

Our recommended option!

Pella

While Pella has some good qualities it loses points due to some limitations when compared to other companies on this list.

Warranty Length: Varies

Transferable Warranty: Depends

Maintenance Required: Yes

Material: Vinyl, Wood, Fiberglass

Financing: Convenient Monthly Payments

Installation: Pella Installation Team

Custom Design: 5 Operable Shapes

Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

On the plus side, Pella offers convenient online scheduling and financing. However, there are some issues that may affect your decision. First, Pella constructs windows using traditional materials that each have their own drawback. Wooden frames are susceptible to rot and decay; fiberglass windows are prone to exterior water leakage and vulnerable to UV damage; and vinyl windows are known to warp and have issues with sealants. Plus, if you’re looking for custom design options, they only offer 5 window shapes that are operable.

Finally, Pella’s warranty has a few issues. First, it’s incredibly complex. Each component of the window has varying warranty lengths. For example, your glass and your hardware may have different warranty lengths. Second, you’ll have to keep up with maintenance on your windows, otherwise your warranty becomes void.

Marvin

Marvin has offerings comparable to other companies examined. However, there are a few things to look out for that prevent Marvin from achieving a higher rating.

Warranty Length: Varies

Transferable Warranty: Depends

Maintenance Required: Yes

Material: Wood, Extruded Aluminum, Fiberglass

Financing: Promotional Period

Installation: Marvin Replacement, Infinity from Marvin, and Certified Installing Retailers

Custom Design: Options for each Material

Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Like Pella, Marvin has decent offerings for materials and a warranty that varies, but on closer inspection, there are a few things to be wary of. Starting with the warranty, you’ll want to make sure you really dig into it to understand the specifics. Like Pella, your warranty will cover different pieces of the window for different lengths of time. Plus, you’ll also have to keep up with maintenance yourself to keep the warranty valid. Finally, the installation partner you choose will affect the quality of the work. You’ll have to do extra research to determine which partner is right for you and your home.

CHAMPION window

Champion

Of the four window replacement companies compared here, Champion suffers the most from limited options specifically in the material category. Combined with lackluster offerings in other areas, Champion had stiff competition to compete with.

Warranty Length: 20 Years

Transferable Warranty: No

Maintenance Required: Yes
Material: Vinyl

Financing: Promotional Period

Installation: Champion Install Crew

Custom Design: Range of colors and designs

Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️

First and foremost, Champion only makes windows with vinyl frames. However, there are some major issues that you may encounter with vinyl windows like warping and the sealing of the windows. With only one material option available, Champion loses significant points compared to others on this list. With average offerings in other categories and a total lack of a transferable warranty, Champion stands apart from Pella, Renewal by Andersen, and Marvin for the wrong reasons.

Overall Takeaway

Replacing the windows in your home is a big decision and working with a company that can offer you quality service and products is key to ensuring that you’re happy with the final results.

For that reason, one of these companies rose above the others, excelling in every category. Our preferred choice of window replacement company is Renewal by Andersen. With the nation’s best warranty coverage, RBA does not require maintenance, unlike most window replacement companies that demand proof of regular maintenance before any issues occur. They also provide hundreds of custom design options, Certified Master Installers, convenient scheduling, and budget-friendly financing, offering the most impressive service and products.

If you’re searching for quality products and service, Renewal by Andersen is definitely worthy of taking a look and making an appointment to see what they can do for you and your home.